merge: preserve tested Copilot install sources 2960 and 2963

This commit is contained in:
haelyra committed 2026-10-09 16:09:01 -04:00
commit 2ad3bdbef4
15 files changed
+580 -28

No files matched your search

+118 -11
View File
@@ -408,8 +408,9 @@ cd ECC
| Kimi Code CLI | `./install.sh --profile minimal --target kimi` | Project-local `.kimi-code/` install · [Get Kimi Code](https://www.kimi.ai/code?aff=ecc) |
| CodeBuddy | `./install.sh --profile minimal --target codebuddy` | Project-local `.codebuddy/` install |
| JoyCode | `./install.sh --profile minimal --target joycode` | Project-local `.joycode/` install |
| GitHub Copilot | `./install.sh --profile full --target copilot` | Installs skills to `.github/skills/` and agents to `.github/agents/` for Copilot CLI |
GitHub Copilot support is already included in this repository. `.github/copilot-instructions.md` provides the instruction layer, `.github/prompts/` contains the reusable `/plan`, `/tdd`, `/security-review`, `/build-fix`, and `/refactor` prompts, and `.vscode/settings.json` enables `chat.promptFiles`.
GitHub Copilot support is already included in this repository. `.github/copilot-instructions.md` provides the instruction layer, `.github/prompts/` contains the reusable `/plan`, `/tdd`, `/security-review`, `/build-fix`, and `/refactor` prompts, and `.vscode/settings.json` enables `chat.promptFiles`. GitHub Copilot CLI additionally discovers the `.agents/skills/` subset from a plain clone with no setup; see [Platform Support](#platform-support) for the full catalog and agents.
For a harness without a native ECC target, use the [manual adaptation guide](docs/MANUAL-ADAPTATION-GUIDE.md). It explains how to carry a small set of ECC skills and workflow instructions into chat-style tools without pretending hooks or native skill discovery are available.
@@ -1291,7 +1292,8 @@ Treat `stable`, `beta`, `experimental`, and `instruction-only` below as capabili
| Codex | Supported native plugin | Codex marketplace plugin or repo config | Native hooks require an explicit trust decision and do not use Claude's hook profiles. The legacy sync is compatibility-only. |
| Cursor | Beta project adapter | Selective installer into `.cursor/` | Agent discovery varies by Cursor build, and ECC's installer paths do not yet expose identical hook sets ([#2419](https://github.com/affaan-m/ECC/issues/2419)). |
| OpenCode | Beta built plugin | Build plugin, then selective installer | ECC ships a subset of the catalog; connect a provider and select a model in OpenCode ([#2617](https://github.com/affaan-m/ECC/issues/2617)). |
| GitHub Copilot | Instruction-only | Checked-in instructions and prompt files | No ECC hooks, runtime agents, delegation, or native skill discovery. |
| GitHub Copilot Chat | Instruction-only | Checked-in instructions and prompt files | ECC hooks are not adapted. |
| GitHub Copilot CLI | Beta project adapter | `--target copilot` places skills and adapted agents in `.github/` | ECC hooks, rules, and command shims are not installed by this target. |
| Gemini, Zed, Antigravity, Qwen, Hermes, OpenClaw, Kimi, CodeBuddy, JoyCode | Experimental/minimal adapters | Harness-specific selective target | File placement and instruction portability are tested; full Claude feature parity is not claimed. |
<details>
@@ -1400,16 +1402,16 @@ See [affaan-m/ECC#2065](https://github.com/affaan-m/ECC/issues/2065).
| Capability | Claude Code | Codex | Cursor | OpenCode | GitHub Copilot |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Instructions | Native | Native `AGENTS.md` | Project rules | Plugin instructions | Native instruction file |
| Skills | Native installed set | Native plugin set | Build-dependent/project set | Built subset | Prompt/instruction references only |
| Agents/delegation | Native agents | Codex multi-agent roles; Claude agent files are not installed as roles | Build-dependent project agents | Plugin agents | Not supported |
| ECC hooks | Native plugin hooks | Native reviewed subset with explicit trust | Cursor hook adapter; install-path differences remain | Plugin events | Not supported |
| Skills | Native installed set | Native plugin set | Build-dependent/project set | Built subset | Native discovery (Copilot CLI) from `.github/skills/`, `.agents/skills/`, `.claude/skills/` |
| Agents/delegation | Native agents | Codex multi-agent roles; Claude agent files are not installed as roles | Build-dependent project agents | Plugin agents | Copilot CLI custom agents via `.github/agents/` and `--agent` |
| ECC hooks | Native plugin hooks | Native reviewed subset with explicit trust | Cursor hook adapter; install-path differences remain | Plugin events | Not ported; Copilot CLI has its own plugin hook system |
| MCP configuration | Available, explicit activation | Native plugin manifest; legacy sync can merge TOML | Explicit project/user config | Provider/plugin config | Not supplied by ECC |
| Parity with Claude Code | Primary reference | Partial | Partial | Partial | Not a parity target |
| Parity with Claude Code | Primary reference | Partial | Partial | Partial | Partial |
**Key architectural decisions:**
- **AGENTS.md** at root is the universal cross-tool file (read by Claude Code, Cursor, Codex, and OpenCode; GitHub Copilot uses `.github/copilot-instructions.md` instead)
- **DRY adapter pattern** lets Cursor reuse Claude Code's hook scripts without duplication
- **Skills format** (SKILL.md with YAML frontmatter) works across Claude Code, Codex, and OpenCode
- **Skills format** (SKILL.md with YAML frontmatter) works across Claude Code, Codex, OpenCode, and GitHub Copilot CLI
- Codex's narrower native hook set is supplemented by `AGENTS.md`, optional `model_instructions_file` overrides, and sandbox permissions
<details>
@@ -1653,7 +1655,7 @@ For the full ECC OpenCode setup, either:
<details>
<summary><strong>GitHub Copilot support in depth</strong></summary>
ECC provides **GitHub Copilot support** for VS Code via Copilot Chat's native instruction and prompt file system. No extra tooling required.
ECC supports **GitHub Copilot** on two surfaces: Copilot Chat in VS Code, via its native instruction and prompt file system, and **GitHub Copilot CLI**, which discovers the shared skills already present in this repository. The optional `copilot` install target places canonical skills and adapted agents in the CLI's native project directories.
#### What's included for GitHub Copilot
@@ -1674,6 +1676,99 @@ To use the workflow prompts in Copilot Chat:
2. Click the **paperclip / attach** icon and select **Prompt...**, or type `/` and choose a prompt.
3. Select the prompt (e.g. `plan`, `tdd`, `security-review`).
#### Copilot CLI: skills and agents
GitHub Copilot CLI discovers `SKILL.md` skills from `.github/skills/`,
`.agents/skills/`, `.claude/skills/`, `~/.copilot/skills/`, and
`~/.agents/skills/`, and custom agents from `.github/agents/`. ECC's skill and
skill frontmatter is compatible. The managed `copilot` target adapts agent
frontmatter to `name` and `description`, removing Claude-specific model and
tool keys. Raw manual agent copies can retain unsupported metadata.
Because ECC ships a skill subset in `.agents/skills/`, a plain clone of this
repository is picked up by Copilot CLI with no configuration at all:
```bash
git clone https://github.com/affaan-m/ECC.git && cd ECC
copilot skill list
# The inventory depends on the checkout and CLI version.
```
In the contributor's September 2026 checkout, Copilot CLI 1.0.83 reported all 42 under `Project skills` with `source:
"project"` and `enabled: true`. The three from `.claude/commands/` are Claude
command files that Copilot surfaces as skills; they are reported with `path`
set to the `.claude/commands` directory rather than to a per-skill subdirectory.
To check this with a temporary npm-distributed CLI, run the pinned build
against a throwaway clone:
```bash
git clone --depth 1 https://github.com/affaan-m/ECC.git && cd ECC
npx -y @github/copilot@1.0.82 skill list --json | jq '[.[] | select(.source=="project")] | length'
# Count the current inventory rather than assuming a fixed total.
```
That checkout's 39 + 3 split was reported by 1.0.82 from npm and by 1.0.83 installed
locally, so the behaviour is not specific to one build or install method.
To expose the full catalog, place `skills/` where Copilot CLI looks:
```bash
mkdir -p .github/skills
cp -r skills/. .github/skills/
copilot skill list --json > copilot-skills.json
jq '[.[] | select(.path | contains(".github/skills"))] | length' copilot-skills.json
# Compare with the current canonical skill catalog.
```
Filter on the path rather than on `source`: the CLI can also discover skills
from other project locations and de-duplicates entries with the same skill
name. Counts depend on the checkout and CLI version. The file redirection also
avoids truncated large JSON output observed with Copilot CLI 1.0.82 on macOS.
Copilot registers a skill under the `name` in its `SKILL.md` frontmatter, not
its directory name, so catalog folders whose names differ from their frontmatter
(for example `scientific-db-pubmed-database`, which declares
`name: pubmed-database`) still load — they are just listed under the frontmatter
name.
Agents work the same way:
```bash
./install.sh --profile full --target copilot
copilot --agent architect -p "Review this module's boundaries"
```
The contributor verified native discovery with Copilot CLI 1.0.83. Manually
copied agent files that declare a Claude model
name (`model: opus`, `model: sonnet`) emit a warning and fall back to the
session's default model, so remove or remap `model:` if you want to pin one.
#### Installing with the `copilot` target
The steps above copy files by hand. The `copilot` install target does the same
placement and additionally rewrites agent frontmatter so no warning is emitted:
```bash
./install.sh --profile full --target copilot
# Windows: ./install.ps1 --profile full --target copilot
```
That writes skills to `.github/skills/`, agents to `.github/agents/`, and an
install-state file to `.github/ecc-install-state.json`. Nothing is written
outside `.github/`.
The `full` profile selects the modules declared for Copilot. It can place fewer
skills than a manual copy of the entire canonical catalog because modules
that require another host's runtime are excluded. List the resulting native
inventory to see what this checkout installs; a count is not a capability grant.
Claude-only agent frontmatter (`model`, `tools`, `color`) is dropped during the
copy: Copilot resolves the model from your own configuration, and it governs
tool access per session through `--allow-tool`/`--deny-tool` rather than through
agent frontmatter. ECC's rules, commands, and hooks are not installed by this
target.
#### Feature coverage
| ECC Feature | Copilot equivalent |
@@ -1686,12 +1781,24 @@ To use the workflow prompts in Copilot Chat:
| Build error resolution | `build-fix` prompt |
| Refactoring | `refactor` prompt |
| Commit message format | Per-task instruction in `settings.json` |
| Hooks / automation | Not supported (Copilot has no hook system) |
| Agents / delegation | Not supported (Copilot has no subagent API) |
| Skills | Native discovery in Copilot CLI (`.github/skills/`, `.agents/skills/`) |
| Agents / delegation | Copilot CLI custom agents (`.github/agents/`, `--agent`) |
| Hooks / automation | ECC's hooks are not ported (Copilot CLI has its own plugin hook system) |
#### Limitations
GitHub Copilot does not have a hook system or a subagent API, so ECC's hook automations (auto-format, TypeScript check, session persistence, dev-server guard) and agent delegation are unavailable. The instruction and prompt layer still brings the full ECC coding philosophy (standards, security, TDD, and workflow) into every Copilot Chat session.
ECC's hook automations (auto-format, TypeScript check, session persistence,
dev-server guard) are written against Claude Code's hook event model and are
not ported to Copilot. Copilot CLI does expose a hook system through its plugin
format, but ECC does not currently ship a Copilot plugin, so none of ECC's hooks
run there.
ECC also does not install rules, commands, or hooks for Copilot. The `copilot`
target installs skills and agents only. Skills that shell out to bundled
scripts assume the same interpreters as on Claude Code. Copilot Chat in VS Code
does not read `.github/skills/` or `.github/agents/`; those paths are Copilot
CLI surfaces. The instruction and prompt layer is what carries ECC's coding
philosophy into Copilot Chat sessions.
</details>
<details>