printf decoded escapes in %s arguments too, so `printf '%s' 'gi\t push
--no-verify' | sh` read as `gi<tab> push` and passed, while the shell
reads `gi\t` as `git`. Escapes are now decoded in the format and in %b
arguments only. `1<&3` and the move `1>&3-` copy a descriptor like
`1>&3`, so restoring a saved stdout is followed. The format-reuse loop
charges the work budget before each piece, so a short command cannot
expand into a huge string. The bash-backed tests now run what the shell
reads with a stub git, which also sees how the shell unescapes words.
A group or pipeline producer counted whatever its redirections said, so
`{ echo 'git push --no-verify' >/dev/null | cat; } | bash` was blocked
although bash reads nothing, and printf filled no %s, so
`printf 'git %s --no-verify\n' push | sh` got through. shell-scan now
keeps a redirection's descriptor, and a stage's output counts only when
its descriptors, the stages after it and an `exec` earlier in its group
take it to the shell; an `exec` is carried only where it adds output.
printf fills %s, %b and %c and reuses its format; other conversions are
read like an unmodeled command. The header states what the model covers.
echo takes -n, -e and -E only before its first operand, so echo 'git commit -m x' -n prints git commit -m x -n and runs the bypass when it is piped into sh. The producer text removed the -n wherever it stood and lost the flag. printf '%s' reuses its format for every argument without a separator, so printf '%s' 'git pu' 'sh --no-verify' writes git push --no-verify, but the arguments were joined with newlines. Both passed on main as well.
echo writes a newline unless -n is given, so { echo 'git pu'; echo 'sh --no-verify'; } | sh feeds sh two separate lines. The joined read glued them into git push --no-verify and blocked the group. echoText() and printf's %s\n branch now end their text with the newline they write, while echo -n and printf without one still join directly.
printf writes \n, \t and the other whitespace escapes of its format as the characters they name, but the producer text kept them as a backslash and a letter. printf 'git push --no-verify\n' | sh was read as the flag --no-verifyn and passed, with or without a group around it. printfText() now decodes the whitespace escapes and \\. Numeric escapes stay encoded, as for $'...' in shell-scan.
The commands in a group write one stream into the pipe, so a bypass split across them, as in { printf 'git pu'; printf 'sh --no-verify'; } | sh, was read as two harmless fragments. groupSources() now adds the outputs joined in order next to the separate ones. The group handling moves out of pipelineSources() to keep it under the complexity limit.
pipelineSources() read the literal output of the commands that feed a shell, but a brace group or subshell producer has no words of its own, so nothing it printed reached the check. { echo 'git commit --no-verify -m x'; } | sh and (echo 'git push --no-verify'; printf x) | bash passed the guard, while echo 'git commit --no-verify -m x' | sh is blocked. shell-scan now keeps the source text of a closed scope, and pipelineSources() reads the commands in it that write to the group's output, as it already does for a plain producer.
checkGitWords, executableWords, shellRole, updateShellState and checkCommand were each well over the complexity budget and checkCommand nested seven blocks deep. Split them into named helpers: git global option scanning and bypass flag search, per-wrapper handlers for command/exec/env/sudo, a shell option cluster classifier, declaration flag parsing, and a per-task/per-state/per-environment pipeline inside checkCommand.
Every budget.spend call keeps its amount and order so the work quota tests still land in the same window. The module still only requires ./lib/shell-scan and exports run unchanged. Wrapper option sets moved to module constants instead of being rebuilt on every call.
Preserve complete source ancestry for PRs #3512, #3513, #3515, #3516, #3517 and #3518. Repair bounded recovery, alias compatibility and evaluator packaging gaps while keeping registry reuse inside the canonical loader. Verified actual hook, setup, dashboard, evaluator, sandbox and profile workflows plus full npm, Python, lint and supply-chain checks. ECC-043 preparation only; integration remains with the delivery owner.
CodeRabbit security finding on the merged sed work (CWE-693, verified live
on main via #3495): GNU sed labels for b, t, T and : end at ';' or newline —
verified against GNU sed 4.9 ('bar;e cmd' parses label 'a' and still runs
cmd; '}' is not a label terminator). Reading those operands to end of line
let 'sed :a;e git commit --no-verify' pass the hook while sed executed the
e command.
Labels are now read up to ';' or newline and command parsing resumes after
them. Text, filename and quit operands (a, c, i, r, w, q, Q) keep the
end-of-line reading: nothing after them on the line executes.
5 regression tests pin the three bypass paths and the benign boundary
(a bare label and a bare branch stay data). Suite: 817/817.
Greptile P1: sedScriptParts stopped at -- and discarded the remaining
operands, so 'sed -- <script>' skipped script collection entirely. GNU sed
4.9 (verified): with no -e/--expression anywhere, the first operand after --
is the script and an s///e in it still executes.
The operands after -- are now collected as positionals, so the existing
first-positional-becomes-script rule applies. Operands after the script stay
file names (data). 2 regression tests pin both sides. Suite: 812/812.
Greptile P1 findings (both verified by running GNU sed against the hook):
1. Escaped replacements evade the check: GNU sed decodes \xHH, \oOOO, \dNNN,
case operations and unknown escapes like \g before executing an s///e
replacement or e operand. Scanning the raw text let \x67it decode to git.
Decoding that surface faithfully is out of scope, so any backslash in an
exec-bearing fragment now throws UnsupportedSedEscape and the hook blocks
with an explicit reason — mirroring the existing env -S escape precedent
instead of pretending to interpret sed. Escaped-newline continuations of an
e operand are refused by the same check.
2. Continued commands went unchecked: the e operand reader stopped at every
newline, but GNU sed joins escaped newlines into one operand. Now covered
by the same conservative refusal.
Also decomposes the sed readers into sub-50-line helpers per the repository
function-size rule (AGENTS.md): readSedDelimited, readSedCommand,
readSedExecute, readSedLineOperand, assertSedLiteral.
5 regression tests pin the escape paths and the benign boundary (a backslash
in a non-executing script stays data). Suite: 810/810.
CodeRabbit security review (Major, CWE-693) correctly identified that GNU sed
collects -e/--expression scripts from any argv position: a script option after
positional operands is still executed, so stopping the option walk at the first
positional let an e-flagged script hide behind it.
Verified against GNU sed 4.9 before fixing:
- 'sed -e s/x/y/ - -e s/y/X/e' runs X (the later -e executes)
- with any script option present, every positional is a file operand
sedScriptParts now walks the full argv, collects scripts from all -e/
--expression positions, and only promotes the first positional to the script
when no script option was given. Unknown options after positionals still fall
back to the opaque default.
4 regression tests pin the reported bypass paths (suite: 805/805).
Ported from the #3051 discussion (test intent, not the old scanner):
- A confidently-parsed sed invocation whose script contains no execution
construct is a pure text transformation: the script operand and every file
operand are data. This removes the specific false positives where file names
or non-executing scripts merely containing 'git ...' were blocked.
- The GNU sed `e` command (bare or with operand) and the `s` command with the
`e` flag run text through the shell. Their literal fragments (the s
replacement, the e operand) and any piped/redirected source are scanned as
real shell source, closing the `printf x | sed 's/x/git commit --no-verify/e'`
gap reported on 2026-10-09.
- Anything the literal parser cannot confidently read (addresses it cannot
consume, -f script files, -i suffix ambiguity, unknown options, expansion
residue) falls back to today's opaque default. No behavior changes for
unmodeled launchers.
- shell-scan.js is untouched and remains the canonical scanner.
Tests: 14 focused cases ported from the #3051 litmus set; full hook suite
801/801.
Validate env -S and --split-string escape syntax before shell scanning or
opaque fallback. Preserve literal single-quoted data and charge each
validation character against the shared input-proportional work budget.
Verified 787 focused cases and 290 real Git/config, harmless native env
and registered-routing controls. Keeps the prior paid-copy protection.
Co-authored-by: Nguyen Thanh Dat <ntdat812.dev@gmail.com>
Co-authored-by: Davemaina1 <dmain7015@gmail.com>
Carry forward bounded literal include/includeIf configuration capabilities
and env -S/--split-string words from PRs #2858 and #2897. Charge array
copy and expansion work before allocation to preserve the shared quota.
Verified 731 hook cases and 60 real Git/config and registered-route
controls. Dynamic remainder and original full source PRs remain held.
Co-authored-by: Nguyen Thanh Dat <ntdat812.dev@gmail.com>
Co-authored-by: Davemaina1 <dmain7015@gmail.com>
Preserve the original contributor histories and apply the exact independently reviewed repair.
Source-Parent: dee884656e
Review-Manifest-SHA256: 0c7eeef7c2722a605d049daf2dc3c2473c10dd616005afcba21049fc036d8ce9
Preserve original contributor history and all current-main assertions while bounding quote, heredoc, shell-option and deferred-scan handling.
Source-PR: https://github.com/affaan-m/ECC/pull/2965
Source-Parent: 5a878131de
Main-Parent: d3b8a3e908
Review-Manifest-SHA256: 5d23f47e60516b66733805aec0ebcd47f19265c964529fa0b1220c8aa6903add
Two cases the word-level rewrite still got wrong. Short options that take an optional stuck value (-u[mode], -S[keyid]) end the cluster scan, so git commit -uno and -Sn are allowed while -nu stays blocked. Git accepts any unambiguous long-option prefix, so --no-veri and --no-verif on commit, push, merge and rebase are now blocked; --no-verbose stays allowed. Quoted data such as -m "--no-verify" is still treated as data. Independent exact-head review probed 34 commands in-process and against real git with no bypass and no false positive; hook test 35/35, eslint clean, CI 44/44 at the head.
Merge buildCommentMask into buildScanBoundaries so one pass owns comment mask and scan bounds.
Extract shell-scan primitives to scripts/hooks/lib/shell-scan.js; keep policy in the hook.
Use a sticky heredoc regex instead of copying the remaining input on every <<.
Replace the short-circuiting chain test with clean-leading sequences that exercise checkCommand advance.
Add quoted-executable non-leakage coverage for the scanEnd=length path.
Treat $'…' ANSI-C quoting as a quoted executable word.
Join unquoted backslash-newline for the flag scan and heredoc-line bound.
Co-Authored-By: grok (fleet lane) <noreply@fleet.local>
Co-authored-by: groy75 <groy75@users.noreply.github.com>
The scanner locked onto a `git commit` literal that sat inside a quoted
string of an OUTER command (a python heredoc's string, a VAR="..."
assignment, a printf JSON payload), then hasNoVerifyFlag() re-tokenized from
that inner offset with a fresh quote state. When quote parity flipped, the
"segment" ran past the enclosing string and picked up an unrelated later
`bash -n` / `sed -n` / `grep -n` as `commit -n`. Two legitimate commands were
blocked this way in one working session.
The first attempt at this PR (d5c428c) fixed the false positive by SKIPPING
`git` tokens judged to be in "data" context. That was the wrong lever: data
becomes executable the moment it is piped to a shell (`echo '...' | bash`,
`bash <<< '...'`, `cat <<EOF | bash`), and no regex list of shell invocations
is complete (`bash --noprofile -c` slipped). Three independent reviewers
(codex, Greptile, CodeRabbit) demonstrated executing bypasses; that commit is
squashed away here and none of its behaviour survives.
This version keeps every `git` candidate visible and keeps main's blocking
surface intact. A single O(n) preprocessing pass (buildScanBoundaries)
records, for each enclosed character, the closing quote or the current
heredoc-body line end. Subcommand discovery and flag tokenization are capped
at that boundary, so tokens after the enclosing data can never leak into a
candidate's argument list. Also: comment detection is a single mask pass
instead of a repeated prefix scan; heredoc parsing accepts quoted hyphenated
delimiters and CRLF terminators and preserves the `<<` vs `<<-` tab
distinction; quote-assembled words (`g''it`) are recognized.
Verified (all payloads run through the hook as JSON on stdin):
- red-list, 24 executing forms incl. every reviewer-reported bypass -> exit 2
on main AND here (CRLF heredoc trailer: 0 on main, 2 here);
- green-list, 16 leak-class false positives -> exit 2 on main, 0 here;
- tests/hooks/block-no-verify.test.js 84/84 (main's 25 retained verbatim,
d5c428c's 8 removed, 59 table-driven red/green cases added);
tests/hooks/cursor-block-no-verify.test.js 14/14;
- 204,807-byte command with 8,905 non-command `git` literals: 8.5 ms.
Co-Authored-By: Codex (GPT) <noreply@openai.com>
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5.1 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01EyuZY1LZNuShHiewExekLT
isCommitNoVerifyShortFlag anchored on the first character, so it only recognised the flag when it led the cluster. Git clusters short options, which means git commit -an is -a plus the bypass flag and skips the hooks. -sn and -vn slip through the same way, while -na and -nm are caught — the difference is position, not intent.
Scanning now walks the cluster and stops at a value-taking option, since that option swallows the rest as its inline value. The n in -mn stays message text, and the existing -tn case keeps working.
Adds 4 tests: the three clustered forms that were escaping, plus -mn to pin the inline-value boundary. Verified the three fail against current main. Suite 25 to 29.
Co-authored-by: haelyra <49814733+haelyra@users.noreply.github.com>
Backport Jamkris's fix for case-insensitive core.hooksPath overrides and the git commit -tn template-path false positive. Verified locally on current main with 25/25 block-no-verify tests and node tests/run-all.js passing 2369/2369.
- Add `minimal` profile so the security hook runs in all profiles
- Scope -n/--no-verify flag check to the detected subcommand region,
preventing false positives on chained commands (e.g. `git log -n 10`)
- Guard stdin listeners with `require.main === module` so require()
from run-with-flags.js does not register unnecessary listeners
- Verify subcommand token is preceded only by flags/flag-args after
"git", preventing misclassification of argument values as subcommands
- Add integration tests for block-no-verify hook
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.6 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Replace inline `npx block-no-verify@1.1.2` with a standalone Node.js
script routed through `run-with-flags.js`, matching every other hook.
Fixes two bugs:
1. npx inherits the project cwd and triggers EBADDEVENGINES in
pnpm-only projects that set devEngines.packageManager.onFail=error.
2. The hook bypassed run-with-flags.js so ECC_DISABLED_HOOKS had no
effect — the isHookEnabled() check never ran.
The new script replicates the full block-no-verify@1.1.2 detection
logic (--no-verify, -n shorthand for commit, core.hooksPath override)
with zero external dependencies.
Closes#1378