fix(mcp): name the close_binary retry for retained cleanup (#8329)

* fix(mcp): name the close_binary retry for retained cleanup

A close_binary that retired its target but could not confirm cleanup
returned cleanup_incomplete with retryable: false and only the generic
"Review the reported local resources" remediation, although the session
keeps every failed owner and the next close_binary on the same connection
retries them. Agents could abandon the connection that owns the only retry.

The MCP close tool now passes its retry operation to the session. The
session binds that typed AnalysisCleanupRetry to a failed retirement only
while it retains the cleanup for its next close; the close tool binds it to
process-capture failures its own scope retains and to compositions whose
session part was offered. Projection then reports
recovery.kind=retry_cleanup and appends a conditional instruction: keep the
connection, let the condition settle or resolve it, call close_binary
without snapshot_path and check the result. The hint disappears once that
cleanup resolves. retryable keeps describing the failed operation.

One-shot CLI closes, open_binary, analysis tools and failed snapshot saves
(which keep the target open) offer no retry. Cleanup composition copies the
owner's remediation without a retry offer, so the text appears once.

Fixes #8211

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>

* test: derive close retry guidance from its owning formatters

The new close_binary retry assertions froze ProviderCleanupError's
explanatory sentence, so a harmless wording edit would break them. The MCP
test now compares delivered remediation with analysisErrorRemediationAction
applied to the delivered typed error plus cleanupRetryRemediation. The
domain tests use the same formatters, check that unbound and released errors
carry no retry text, and check that a bound composition adds the offer once.
Recovery fields, cleanup state and retry behavior keep separate assertions.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>

---------

Co-authored-by: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
This commit is contained in:
Kaoru0822andClaude Opus 5.5 authored and GitHub committed 2026-10-31 11:12:30 -07:00
1 parent c534e249d1
commit 8a6ddec83a
16 files changed
+659 -32

No files matched your search

+1
View File
@@ -50,6 +50,7 @@ harm_rank,location,trigger,current_copy,user_risk,proposed_replacement,implement
36,src/main/reportMcpTransportError.ts:reportMcpTransportError,MCP error has no known validation or disconnection identity,MCP reported an error with unknown connection state. Check whether the client is still connected before following connection-loss recovery.,Connection state remains unknown,Keep current copy,implemented,injected unknown-error recovery regression
37,src/main.ts:serveStdio throw,MCP connection cannot be created,Failed to start MCP stdio transport,Exposes transport implementation and gives no recovery,"Retry once. If it fails again, tell the user REA could not start its MCP connection and ask them to restart the MCP client, then run `rea doctor`.",implemented,verified by injected transport startup-throw runtime test
38,src/main.ts:requestShutdown catch,Connection or analysis session close rejects,Failed to shut down cleanly,Does not explain duplicate-process risk or recovery,REA could not close cleanly. End the REA process before starting it again.,implemented,verified by injected handle-close rejection runtime test
38.5,src/domain/analysisErrorRecovery.ts:cleanupRetryRemediation,close_binary returns cleanup_incomplete while the session retains the failed cleanup owners,"Provider cleanup could not be fully confirmed. Review the reported local resources before opening another target. (retryable: false, no recovery)",Agent could abandon the connection that owns the only cleanup retry,"Append: This connection retains that cleanup. Keep it open; after the reported condition settles or is resolved, call close_binary without snapshot_path and check its result. That call retries the retained cleanup without rerunning the failed analysis, clears session records like any close_binary, and can report cleanup_incomplete again. Add recovery.kind=retry_cleanup naming close_binary; keep retryable false",implemented,MCP close_binary with the real KunaProvider and a fake Kuna whose export stop stays unproven; process-capture MCP retry; session tests for an unoffered one-shot close and for failed and completed snapshot saves; one-shot IDA CLI cleanup reports no hint; real Kuna not run
39,src/main.ts:entrypoint catch,Unhandled rejection escapes run(),Unexpected server startup failure,Vague and lacks diagnostic recovery,"Do not repeat this startup. Tell the user REA could not start and ask them to restart the MCP client, then run `rea doctor`.",implemented,verified by injected entrypoint rejection test
40,src/application/Update.ts:unknown-install-method,Running package is not owned by detectable global npm installation,Update manually with: npm install --global rea-agents@latest,Old global-npm advice does not identify the owning installation,"Update this installation with the package manager or source checkout that owns it. For a one-off latest invocation, use npx rea-agents@latest.",implemented,36 Update tests passed; public CLI unowned-installation refusal verified with isolated package-manager fixtures
41,src/application/Update.ts:install,npm global install subprocess exits unsuccessfully,npm install --global rea-agents@latest failed.,Old registry/global-install advice omits the actual version prefix and installer failure,"REA could not install {version} in {prefix}: {failure}. Repair this npm installation, then rerun rea update.",implemented,36 Update tests passed; public CLI owned npm fixture failure preserved version prefix and installer reason
1 harm_rank location trigger current_copy user_risk proposed_replacement implementation_status verification_result
50 36 src/main/reportMcpTransportError.ts:reportMcpTransportError MCP error has no known validation or disconnection identity MCP reported an error with unknown connection state. Check whether the client is still connected before following connection-loss recovery. Connection state remains unknown Keep current copy implemented injected unknown-error recovery regression
51 37 src/main.ts:serveStdio throw MCP connection cannot be created Failed to start MCP stdio transport Exposes transport implementation and gives no recovery Retry once. If it fails again, tell the user REA could not start its MCP connection and ask them to restart the MCP client, then run `rea doctor`. implemented verified by injected transport startup-throw runtime test
52 38 src/main.ts:requestShutdown catch Connection or analysis session close rejects Failed to shut down cleanly Does not explain duplicate-process risk or recovery REA could not close cleanly. End the REA process before starting it again. implemented verified by injected handle-close rejection runtime test
53 38.5 src/domain/analysisErrorRecovery.ts:cleanupRetryRemediation close_binary returns cleanup_incomplete while the session retains the failed cleanup owners Provider cleanup could not be fully confirmed. Review the reported local resources before opening another target. (retryable: false, no recovery) Agent could abandon the connection that owns the only cleanup retry Append: This connection retains that cleanup. Keep it open; after the reported condition settles or is resolved, call close_binary without snapshot_path and check its result. That call retries the retained cleanup without rerunning the failed analysis, clears session records like any close_binary, and can report cleanup_incomplete again. Add recovery.kind=retry_cleanup naming close_binary; keep retryable false implemented MCP close_binary with the real KunaProvider and a fake Kuna whose export stop stays unproven; process-capture MCP retry; session tests for an unoffered one-shot close and for failed and completed snapshot saves; one-shot IDA CLI cleanup reports no hint; real Kuna not run
54 39 src/main.ts:entrypoint catch Unhandled rejection escapes run() Unexpected server startup failure Vague and lacks diagnostic recovery Do not repeat this startup. Tell the user REA could not start and ask them to restart the MCP client, then run `rea doctor`. implemented verified by injected entrypoint rejection test
55 40 src/application/Update.ts:unknown-install-method Running package is not owned by detectable global npm installation Update manually with: npm install --global rea-agents@latest Old global-npm advice does not identify the owning installation Update this installation with the package manager or source checkout that owns it. For a one-off latest invocation, use npx rea-agents@latest. implemented 36 Update tests passed; public CLI unowned-installation refusal verified with isolated package-manager fixtures
56 41 src/application/Update.ts:install npm global install subprocess exits unsuccessfully npm install --global rea-agents@latest failed. Old registry/global-install advice omits the actual version prefix and installer failure REA could not install {version} in {prefix}: {failure}. Repair this npm installation, then rerun rea update. implemented 36 Update tests passed; public CLI owned npm fixture failure preserved version prefix and installer reason