mirror of
https://github.com/morluto/rea.git
synced 2026-11-12 01:41:21 +00:00
morluto
cb4e5cfbff
* refactor(analysis): centralize resource budgets and recovery facts * feat(analysis): expose ASAR and Ghidra runtime admission controls * feat(artifacts): expose reader admission and preserve limited recognition * feat(javascript): expose recoverable semantic precision budgets * feat(web): add recoverable source-map budgets and compact retained views * feat(web): make historical capture decoding budgets recoverable * fix(desktop): enforce selected view policies across capture and export * feat(runtime): make Frida and LLDB retention budgets selectable * feat(native): expose diagnostic budgets and preserve exhaustion causes * feat(managed): expose recoverable snapshot and representation budgets * feat(metadata): make Go and Rust inspection budgets recoverable * feat(wasm): expose representation and producer admissions * feat(evm): expose per-call worker resource budgets * feat(android): make resource and string-pool omissions recoverable * feat(producers): expose command and recorded-capture budgets * docs(analysis): record recovery contracts and integrated validation * fix(docs): link calibration oracle from published verification pages * fix(docs): restore desktop task anchors and receipt links * test(analysis): align fixtures with selectable budget contracts * fix(analysis): remove source-location projector dependency cycle * test(analysis): refresh budget recovery and verifier regressions * test(analysis): preserve format and publication recovery expectations * test(windows): align conformance with owned runtime admission * fix(desktop): preserve selected alias kinds in exported state * test(analysis): align provider fixtures with recoverable budgets * test(desktop): validate emitted alias metadata structurally * fix(ghidra): classify bounded Windows endpoint refusals * test(cli): assert selectable artifact admission recovery * fix(cli): preserve capture provenance in environment builds
207 lines
14 KiB
Markdown
207 lines
14 KiB
Markdown
# Source-location delivery qualification — 2026-11-09
|
|
|
|
Opt-in summary delivery substantially reduces the measured main-map task's
|
|
serialized transcript and its median elapsed time, CPU and sampled memory. The
|
|
small Theme control exposes a tradeoff: summary adds a call and becomes more
|
|
expensive when a client must first load the complete `inspect_analysis_view`
|
|
definition. Complete delivery remains the compatibility default. These results
|
|
support explicit summary selection for large point answers or already available
|
|
views; they do not establish a uniform whole-task token or latency improvement.
|
|
|
|
The [product guide](../guides/web/web-source-location.md#compact-point-delivery-and-retained-source-text)
|
|
explains summary, matches pages, explicit UTF-16 source text selection and retained
|
|
complete Evidence. This record measures the public compiled stdio MCP workflow.
|
|
CLI publication performance is unmeasured here.
|
|
|
|
## Task, oracle and execution
|
|
|
|
The task returns every alternative at one generated point, preserving source/map
|
|
identity and original source positions, plus a 512 UTF-16-code-unit snippet around
|
|
each mapped point. Inputs are the pinned public Actual Budget Theme, main
|
|
`index.CMrE7aQb`, and `DateSelect.BVYaCNUe` maps and generated scripts in the existing
|
|
[artifact manifest](https://github.com/morluto/rea/blob/main/docs/verification/source-map-budgets-2026-11-09/artifacts.json). Acquisition used
|
|
verified cached public bytes and the existing acquisition helper's explicitly
|
|
incomplete analyst-manifest construction. No application or browser was executed.
|
|
The independent [VLQ oracle](https://github.com/morluto/rea/blob/main/docs/verification/source-map-budgets-2026-11-09/oracle.py) supplies the
|
|
expected source declarations, positions, alternatives and content digests.
|
|
|
|
Both variants use the same compiled runtime, files and portable driver:
|
|
|
|
- **Complete:** request complete Evidence. Theme and main return it inline; the
|
|
driver selects the required snippet locally from the returned source content.
|
|
DateSelect exceeds the default 10 MiB transport allowance, then follows its
|
|
retained matches continuation and requests the selected source text: three tool
|
|
calls, including the failed delivery.
|
|
- **Summary:** request `detail: summary`, then explicitly request the selected
|
|
source-text page: two tool calls. Match paging remains part of the driver when
|
|
required. All three selected real points have one alternative.
|
|
|
|
This compares current **complete delivery with bounded retained-view recovery**
|
|
against opt-in summary. It does not compare against the former export-only fallback.
|
|
The measurement includes driver artifact hashing/reference parsing, initialization,
|
|
full catalog discovery, trace, necessary continuation/text calls, answer validation
|
|
and shutdown. Export is not needed to answer this task and was not included.
|
|
|
|
Three fresh-process runs per case/variant completed. Trial two reversed variant
|
|
order; OS caches were not flushed. All 18 runs exited zero, with empty owned groups
|
|
and no resource stop. Aggregation independently verifies all snippets and pinned
|
|
map/generated-script/content hashes, identical answers and parent Evidence IDs
|
|
across variants/trials, and exact raw-map SHA-256 whenever the initial complete
|
|
response includes raw text. Runtime execution and deployment authenticity remain
|
|
unknown.
|
|
|
|
## Serialized token estimates
|
|
|
|
Counts use tiktoken 0.12.0 `cl100k_base` on compact Unicode JSON-RPC request/reply
|
|
lines, including initialization, the initialized notification, `tools/list`, failed
|
|
calls, continuations and selected text. Replies include both MCP text and structured
|
|
content. These are serialized-transcript estimates, **not actual model usage or
|
|
billing**; client presentation can omit or transform those representations.
|
|
|
|
The observed full catalog uses compact input schemas and full output schemas.
|
|
`tools/list` returns 4,487,850 wire bytes. Initialization, notification and catalog
|
|
account for **1,145,053 estimated tokens** in every run. Do not add selected
|
|
contracts again to the catalog-included totals. Post-discovery counts exclude only
|
|
that discovery prefix, so they include all task retries and subsequent calls.
|
|
|
|
| Map / delivery | Tool calls | Catalog-included task tokens | Post-discovery tokens |
|
|
| ----------------------------------- | ---------: | ---------------------------: | --------------------: |
|
|
| Theme / complete | 1 | 1,196,400 | 51,347 |
|
|
| Theme / summary | 2 | 1,154,878 | 9,825 |
|
|
| Main / complete | 1 | 4,354,894 | 3,209,841 |
|
|
| Main / summary | 2 | 1,154,851 | 9,798 |
|
|
| DateSelect / complete with recovery | 3 | 1,155,932 | 10,879 |
|
|
| DateSelect / summary | 2 | 1,154,974 | 9,921 |
|
|
|
|
Selected complete wired definitions cost **8,408 tokens** for
|
|
`trace_web_source_location` and **180,576** for `inspect_analysis_view`. When those
|
|
definitions are uncached and a client loads only the tools it uses, Theme complete
|
|
costs 8,408 + 51,347 = **59,755**, whereas summary costs
|
|
8,408 + 180,576 + 9,825 = **198,809**. Summary loses in this first-use accounting
|
|
scenario. The measured full-catalog scenario already loads the view definition,
|
|
so its Theme total instead falls from 1,196,400 to 1,154,878. Main still improves
|
|
with selected complete definitions: 3,218,249 to 198,782.
|
|
|
|
As a separate **hypothetical client projection**, retaining only each definition's
|
|
`{name, description, inputSchema}` costs 548 and 3,533 tokens respectively. Adding
|
|
those selected projected definitions to the same post-discovery transcripts gives:
|
|
|
|
| Case | Complete → summary, selected complete wired definitions | Complete → summary, hypothetical input-only definitions |
|
|
| ---------- | ------------------------------------------------------: | ------------------------------------------------------: |
|
|
| Theme | 59,755 → 198,809 | 51,895 → 13,906 |
|
|
| Main | 3,218,249 → 198,782 | 3,210,389 → 13,879 |
|
|
| DateSelect | 199,863 → 198,905 | 14,960 → 14,002 |
|
|
|
|
This projection is an offline accounting calculation, not an observed client/model
|
|
transformation or an alternate measured discovery workflow. Cached or deferred tool
|
|
loading, output-schema profiles and model-facing reply presentation can change the
|
|
costs. No actual model run or billing comparison was performed.
|
|
|
|
## Elapsed time, CPU and sampled memory
|
|
|
|
Values are medians of three runs on macOS 26.3 arm64 with Node v24.22.1. The small
|
|
control has a slight elapsed/CPU increase; DateSelect memory is similar across
|
|
variants. Three runs do not establish general performance guarantees.
|
|
|
|
| Map / delivery | Wall seconds | CPU seconds, waited subtree | Sampled group peak MiB | Sampled tree peak MiB |
|
|
| ----------------------------------- | -----------: | --------------------------: | ---------------------: | --------------------: |
|
|
| Theme / complete | 0.972 | 1.128 | 498.0 | 555.8 |
|
|
| Theme / summary | 0.985 | 1.143 | 483.9 | 542.1 |
|
|
| Main / complete | 1.625 | 1.815 | 776.5 | 776.5 |
|
|
| Main / summary | 1.134 | 1.294 | 549.7 | 661.4 |
|
|
| DateSelect / complete with recovery | 1.199 | 1.351 | 580.6 | 695.6 |
|
|
| DateSelect / summary | 1.150 | 1.326 | 588.6 | 694.2 |
|
|
|
|
The observer samples simultaneous `ps` RSS sums at nominal 20 ms intervals, plus
|
|
sampling work. **Tree RSS includes
|
|
codec descendants outside the root PGID while their PPID ancestry remains linked.**
|
|
Short peaks, exited/reparented/orphaned descendants can be missed; shared pages can
|
|
be counted repeatedly. These are sampled sums, not kernel peak or private-memory
|
|
measurements. CPU is OS `wait4` user + system for the waited subtree, excluding
|
|
sampler CPU and unwaited/orphaned descendants. Wall time includes observer overhead.
|
|
|
|
The 90-second deadline, 1536 MiB observed memory early stop and cleanup signals apply
|
|
only to the **owned process group**. Observational tree membership grants no signal
|
|
authority. The group guard does not enforce a tree-wide or kernel memory hard cap;
|
|
empty-group cleanup does not prove that an unobserved orphan cannot exist.
|
|
|
|
A preliminary 18-run completed-task matrix used group-only RSS and a temporary
|
|
driver that decoded UTF-8 separately per incoming chunk. It is superseded: codec
|
|
processes can change PGID, and chunk boundaries can split UTF-8. Its local method
|
|
receipts are preserved; **none of its result statistics appear in these tables**.
|
|
All final runs use the retained driver's UTF-8 stream decoder, raw-map digest
|
|
check and the observer's additional read-only tree RSS measurement. The earlier
|
|
[map-admission calibration](source-map-budget-calibration.md) is a separate study.
|
|
|
|
## Retained evidence and reproduction
|
|
|
|
The compact [measurement record](https://github.com/morluto/rea/blob/main/scripts/verify/analysis/source-location-delivery/measurements.json)
|
|
contains 18 numeric records, per-call bytes/token estimates, oracle/answer checks,
|
|
full SHA-256 pins and the compiled-tree digest. Large replies, artifacts and model
|
|
transcripts are not committed. Runtime pins include `dist/mcp/main.js`
|
|
(`9bc4c070f63adc9963f276da20b36ffbbcc77b4079585cadf90d792dd2cc04dd`)
|
|
and the 2,921-file compiled `dist` tree
|
|
(`a8a510499dabc07b3cdf6b164d02e55f2fc6917b696dcc4d23449510e91e80fa`).
|
|
The recorded CLI digest is separately bound to `dist/cli.js`. These pins identify
|
|
the measured build and selected source-location owners. A later unrelated generated
|
|
desktop SQLite diagnostic change and rebuild are outside this snapshot; later
|
|
whole-tree hashes do not replace the measured one.
|
|
|
|
The [portable driver](https://github.com/morluto/rea/blob/main/scripts/verify/analysis/source-location-delivery/task.mjs)
|
|
has SHA-256 `b21ec9d5315682337eb55a4ad208e2145a7397d8d567cdb6653facd3f0bec90e`.
|
|
The [observer](https://github.com/morluto/rea/blob/main/scripts/verify/analysis/budget-calibration-run.py)
|
|
has SHA-256 `c18a06c44715c97ec9cbc76248dfbcd862d0e5ca3cd0c159d868bc7fa1fa9e9f`.
|
|
Use the repository's built runtime and pinned Node. Acquisition refuses changed
|
|
publisher bytes; the existing acquisition helper creates `artifacts.json` and
|
|
analyst manifests under the selected artifact directory.
|
|
|
|
Create a fresh receipt directory and its `runtime.json` before measuring. Keep
|
|
source files and the compiled runtime unchanged throughout all 18 runs and
|
|
aggregation; do not build or edit between them. The compiled-tree hash collected
|
|
afterward identifies the measured runtime under that condition. Aggregate before
|
|
any subsequent rebuild.
|
|
|
|
```sh
|
|
python3 docs/verification/source-map-budgets-2026-11-09/acquire.py \
|
|
docs/verification/source-map-budgets-2026-11-09/artifacts.json /tmp/rea-point-artifacts
|
|
python3 - <<'PY'
|
|
import hashlib, json
|
|
from pathlib import Path
|
|
receipts = Path('/tmp/rea-source-location-measurements')
|
|
receipts.mkdir()
|
|
paths = {
|
|
'driver_sha256': Path('scripts/verify/analysis/source-location-delivery/task.mjs'),
|
|
'observer_sha256': Path('scripts/verify/analysis/budget-calibration-run.py'),
|
|
'cli_sha256': Path('dist/cli.js'),
|
|
}
|
|
metadata = {key: hashlib.sha256(path.read_bytes()).hexdigest()
|
|
for key, path in paths.items() if key != 'cli_sha256'}
|
|
cli = paths['cli_sha256']
|
|
metadata['cli_sha256'] = hashlib.sha256(cli.read_bytes()).hexdigest() if cli.is_file() else None
|
|
(receipts / 'runtime.json').write_text(json.dumps(metadata, indent=2) + '\n')
|
|
PY
|
|
python3 scripts/verify/analysis/budget-calibration-run.py \
|
|
--output /tmp/rea-source-location-measurements/r1-index-summary.metrics.json --cwd "$PWD" \
|
|
--timeout-seconds 90 --memory-mib 1536 -- \
|
|
node scripts/verify/analysis/source-location-delivery/task.mjs "$PWD" \
|
|
'{"artifactDir":"/tmp/rea-point-artifacts","select":"index.","detail":"summary","resultPath":"/tmp/rea-source-location-measurements/r1-index-summary.replies.json"}'
|
|
```
|
|
|
|
Run Theme, main and DateSelect with both detail modes serially, three times, reversing
|
|
variant order for trial two. Use unique receipt/result paths named
|
|
`r1-index-summary.metrics.json` / `.replies.json` (and the corresponding case/trial
|
|
names), preserving the runtime metadata. After measurements, the reusable
|
|
[aggregator](https://github.com/morluto/rea/blob/main/scripts/verify/analysis/source-location-delivery/aggregate.py)
|
|
requires Python with tiktoken 0.12.0 and regenerates the compact record:
|
|
|
|
```sh
|
|
python3 scripts/verify/analysis/source-location-delivery/aggregate.py \
|
|
/tmp/rea-source-location-measurements --repo-root "$PWD" --output /tmp/point-measurements.json
|
|
```
|
|
|
|
The aggregator hashes the compiled tree after performance runs, verifies every
|
|
answer and successful complete raw-map response, and excludes large payloads from
|
|
its output. Analysis still decodes and retains complete Evidence; this study does
|
|
not qualify arbitrary larger maps, batch source-map fetching, browser execution or
|
|
disk-cold behavior.
|